#Dupin series how to

Stones for paving because the stones were noisy and damaging to the hooves of horses.(5 ) This pedestrian topic leads to the Which is the subject of Poe’s journalistic “Street Paving” article advocating the superiority of wooden blocks over In the circle of thought, the fruit peddler suggests the idea of street stones, Holman is correct, the details create a great circle of thought, a form of reasoning Poe disparages in an 1848 “Marginalia”Įntry as a “gross error” ( P 2:324). On the basis of several circumstantial associations, she also considers the actor Chantilly, describedĪs a “little fellow,” to be “a satiric diminutive for Longfellow.”( 4) If Harriet Holman believes that the first link in the chain, the fruiterer, is a reference to Longfellow, a connection she makes through a Nichols, Epicurus, Stereotomy, the street stones, the fruiterer” ( M 2:535). Reconstruction (in reverse order) of the complicated chain of associations: “Chantilly, Orion, Dr.

Of the “double Dupin,” whose mind-reading feat so dazzles the narrator that he does not question the solution to theĭuring his preliminary conversation with the narrator in which they have been discussing horses, Dupin recites his These associations should intensify a reader’s awareness

Although it is tempting to skip over these introductory passagesįor Dupin’s dramatic solution of the murders, the seemingly casual chain of ideas demonstrates what Poe suggests may be “anĮxcited. . .or diseased intelligence” ( M 2:532). Tracing his thoughts in an obscure chain of reasoning by association. While the Devil in “Bon-Bon” explains only what the cat is thinking, Dupin in “Murders” astounds the narrator by Like the Devil in “Bon-Bon,” who also wears green glasses but has no eyes, Dupin allegedly can read minds. Of the Night for her own sake” ( M 2:532), and in “Marie Roget” and “The Purloined Letter” he wearsĭark glasses. Position to the text analogous to Dupin’s position to the crimes he solves.”( 3)ĭupin is manifested in the tales as diabolic as well as godlike.

#Dupin series how to

These later tales may well be, in part, a commentary on “Murders.” DennisĮddings observed that “whatever else they may be about, the Dupin tales are also about how to read Poe, with the reader’s Stolen missile, the letter must be reversed. In another sequel, “The Purloined Letter,” Poe has Dupin demonstrate that, to solve the mystery of the In “The Mystery of Marie Roget,” Poe’s serialized sequel thatĬlosely parallels an actual case, Dupin points evidence away from a gang of murderers, the popular theory as suggested by the press, and Solution to the murders, particularly his assumption of the sailor’s innocence, can be questioned because the sailor’sĬulpability may be more than criminal carelessness. Very end, even though justice is not done to the criminally careless”.( 2) Even Dupin’s Solution to “The Murders in the Rue Morgue” and found that “whimsy, unreality, improbability are all prevalent to the Burton Pollin, for example, examined Dupin’s

Have taken a fresh look at Dupin and suggested implausibilities in his method. Of having supernatural powers,( 1) but recent readings of the three tales in which he plays a part Poe’s famous sleuth, Dupin, has long enjoyed a reputation of being the prototype of fictional detectives and even